living out-carnationally
By living incarnationally we not only model the pattern of humanity set up in the Incarnation but we also create space for mission to take place in organic ways. In this way mission becomes something that ‘fits’ seamlessly into the ordinary rhythms of life, friendships, and community and is thus thoroughly contextualized. Thus these ‘practices’ form a working basis for genuine incarnational mission. But they also provide us with an entry point into an authentic experience of Jesus and His mission. Lindy Croucher, a missionary to the poor in a order called UNOH, likens living incarnationally to the scene in Mary Poppins where Mary takes hold of the children’s hands and steps into the painting. She says that for her, incarnational mission has been like “stepping into the Gospels.” She feels that she is “living inside the Gospels” for the first time.
The incarnation must therefore inform the way we engage the complex multi-cultural world around about us. The members of InnerChange (a missional order among the poor) in San Francisco, Los Angeles, Vietnam, and Cambodia take this very seriously. Not only because they work with the poor and that identification with people in their poverty is essential to a meaningful dialogue with them, but also because it is so thoroughly Biblical. It fully reverberates with God’s own means of reaching us. In order to identify with the poor, all InnerChange workers live voluntarily under the poverty line, spend 80% of their time in the neighborhood, and work to support themselves so that people cannot say ‘you are paid to be among us.’ They also plant indigenous faith communities that become a genuine part of the various people groups they are trying to reach.
This practice of incarnating the gospel informs some of the most remarkable people movements around today. God’s Squad, a missionary order doing mission among outlaw biker gangs, takes the same approach. They have over the years become an actual part of the fabric of the sub-culture and are there when people get to talk about God, Jesus, meaning, as all people do in their own way. They have brought Jesus into the imagination of the underground Biker culture of which they are such a vital part. But this need not be limited to sub-cultures, the poor, and ethnic groups. It must become part of our practice in dealing with the many people that exist around us in everyday life. There are now over 60 pub churches in Australia and no doubt many more in the UK and the US. In the desire to incarnate the gospel into a pub we can see the same impulse at work.
Incarnational ministry essentially means taking the church to the people rather than bringing people to the church. In San Francisco, a remarkable urban missionary named Mark Scandrette embodies the ‘4 P’s’ of incarnational practice in his neighborhood. By actively being part of numerous local groups of artists, community activists, businesses, he brings the presence of Jesus into the lives of people significantly alienated from the church as they know it. His ministry is hard to measure in purely numerical terms, but what is unmistakable is that this invaluable ministry has brought the Kingdom of God much closer to many unchurched people than before.
In the Seattle/Tacoma region, two churches (Soma and Zoë) have chosen to collaborate in reaching students and musicians by actively moving into the social rhythms of these groups and ‘de-churchifying’ their previous expressions of ministry. In order to do this they have rented and purchased buildings and developed them as night clubs, coffee shops, and have established recording studios with direct links to the various musicians in the area. Zoë in particular has taken drastic measures to limit the attractional appeal of the ministry in order to wean members off the consumptive attendance at a ‘service’ and to get them all involved in local expressions of mission. Whilst passive attendance at services is down, the community is now highly engaged in various expressions of local community and the missional reach has been significantly increased through incarnational practices. They all feel that they are now much closer to what it means to be disciples in community.
The Navigators in the US are undergoing a major rethink around missional approaches. One of the newest arms of the movement is called BetterTogether or just B2G. Led by visionary Gary Bradley, groups of friends are partnering to bring the Gospel of Jesus and his Kingdom into their daily environments, as channels of grace and blessing. Alert to where God is working, their aim is to join him in the realities of discipleship in the missional context. Their credo? “Right where you are, God is moving to draw and connect people into the depth, risk and reality of knowing Him.” They also aim at the development of transforming communities incarnating in every sphere of life. Gary’s aim is “to see the story of Jesus planted in new ways among the next generation.”
In Melbourne, Urban Life, a major Pentecostal church has sold its substantial property and buildings to invest in a local shopping mall and to become a direct and active presence in this heart of suburban social life. In the mall they will be fully responsible for creating the social fabric and injecting spirituality into these all too soul-less aspects of modern life. Not only are they financial stakeholders in a profitable project, they are in a real sense bringing the Kingdom into the places where people inhabit on a daily basis. Christian worship and presence has come into the public space.
These are just some of the many ways in which individuals, churches, and missional agencies are moving away from the safety of attractional church and engaging in ways that are missional and incarnational. The net effect of these various expressions of incarnational mission is to seed the gospel into local areas or people groups and thus make it part of the intrinsic fabric of the culture. Furthermore, genuine incarnational presence gives a deeply personal feel to mission as well as creating credibility for proclamation and response. We must never underestimate the power of incarnational practices to bring the gospel near to any people group.
By way of contrast we have distorted the meaning of incarnational mission when as western missionaries we have imposed fledged denominational templates on Third World nations. Not only does this diminish the validity of local culture, but it alienates the local Christians from their cultural surroundings by transposing a Western cultural expression in the place of local ones. The net result is a poor black man in the middle of the bush in Africa, dressed in robes and standing outside of a gothic style church building calling people to worship in ways that barely make sense even to the original cultures which started them. In these cases no attempt is made to contextualize (localize) either gospel or church and we wonder why these have little lasting effect on the surrounding populations. And while the error is easier to spot in the middle of Africa, we do the same thing all across the now highly tribalized West.
Comments
8 Responses to “living out-carnationally”
Leave a Reply






Got to say, awesome post.
Really somes up Incarnational ministry with concrete examples.
I am not sure where everyone has gone? Did I say something?
This past Saturday night Expressions presented a movie night called ‘Expressions of Courage’ at OPC (skipping the formality of church title!). It was phenomenal to see the true story of Canadian Lt. Gen. Romeo A. Dallaire and the experiences which he had in Rwanda in 1994 (For more see here: http://iamjustwondering.net/2008/02/09/shake-hands-with-the-devil-movie-night/). Following the movie I asked a good friend named Ricot to share about his hopes as he plans to return to his home land of Haiti and the dreams he has to inspire his people for “resurrection”. What I did not expect is the impact in which the movie would have on him!
“By way of contrast we have distorted the meaning of incarnational mission when as western missionaries we have imposed fledged denominational templates on Third World nations.” The effects of this very quote resonated with the deeply rooted a personal story Ricot shared that evening and the devastating results which his people have been dealing with over the past 200 + years. What seemed most intriguing is that the previous Haitian national dictator used this very concept to spite his own people with the intention of “whipping out the ‘Catholic/Voodoo’ practitioners”; much of which was done at the ignorance of western diplomacy and Church “competitiveness”.
Hi all, how about you give us all some examples of incarnational ministry in your life and experience?
I run a group for new christians relating bible stories with their own stories. The group was designed to discuss what each member was going through in own lifes. It worked well and people experiencing community and hopeful some healing. Most of group were uneducated and the stories seemed to work best as theology concepts can be too abstract.
The group was running out of local recreation centre and a some teenage Somali muslim refugees asked if could used the courts to play basketball. A month before I TOLD God that wouldnt make basketball a god any more and gave up the sport. The kids asked me to coach them in basketball (God’s got a great sense of humor).
The kids were great to be around and I learnt alot of islam and Somali culture. Had alot of conversations alot christianity and Islam comparing what was similar and different (no disagreements). At the end of the first season, we gave the kids trophies and lunch with halal meat. THe kids commented that no one had treat them with such kindness and respect.
Its amazing if you are in the community, God can do things that you dont plan for and even expect.
Jesus Tribe does a lot of great missional work (Servant Evangelism kind of stuff), but I feel most incarnational when I am at an independent coffee house near a local university. The crowd is really diverse with a lot of non-believers. The conversations are great there and come pretty easy.
I found out later that the employees were really suspicious of me when I first started hanging out there and they heard I was a pastor. They wondered what my agenda was and how long it would be before I showed my “true colors.” After a while (and with generous tipping) they were won over. Now, one of the former workers does some part time work with Jesus Tribe (in addition to bar tending), I did the wedding of another employee, and a Buddhist employee asked a couple weeks ago if I would be a reference for her.
I really love the people who work and hang out there. Its my happy place. We’ve done Alpha there, “community worship,” and have a small Bible study there with mostly recovering addicts every other Monday night.
I just try to meet people, wherever they’re at, wherever I am.
So, conversations about life, the universe and Christianity with collegues at work, with neighours at home, with people I meet online.
We live in a very socio-economically and cultural-religiously diverse area so the people I meet and mix with include NeoPagans, Hindus, Buddhists, Sikhs, Atheists and whateverists who just make it up as they go along, ranging from the relatively successful in life to down and out with drugs and brokeness. It’s because of my experiences with the more broken that I am currently studying counseling, so that I might love them more effectively.
I find it’s a lot like the parable of the seeds. The seeds we scatter don’t always take root but sometimes they do. Either way I know I am where God wants me to be. The Christian community I am part of is fairly attractional when its all said and done. I wish it were otherwise, but I’m at a life stage where I can’t go it alone and they’re all I’ve got. So I try to scatter seeds there too. I network with a lot of missional-incarnational Christians beyond that so that we might mutually encourage one another. Just taking it as it comes.
Yeah guys! Thanks Todd. One day I will come and see what you are doing. Good stories. Same with you Mattie. Are you talking about Newtown by the way?
I am located much more west, closer to Parramatta and Mars Hill Cafe, just down the road between
http://www.sydneymurugan.org.au/murugan
and this
http://www.paganawareness.net.au/fullmoon.html
and not so far from this either
http://www.hillsong.com.au
Suburban rather than inner city.
Welcome for dinner anytime you’re in the neighbourhood.